Posted by Lou Pilder on March 21, 2007, at 17:01:18
DR. Hsiung,
Here is a summation of my requests to you that in response to your reminder procedure, I feel that I am still unsure as to what your rationales are for the concerns of mine in question here.
Here is a summery of some of the aspects of the last 6 reminders that I have posted that I would like for you to respond to and then I could have the opportunity to respond accordingly.
A. What in your opinion could be the potential of the effect that the statement in question could have on the current reader toward the Jewish people, if any?
I am reminding you of this request from me to you that I have not seen a reply from you to me here. I am unsure as to what you mean because you have posted that,[...My appraoch to civility is, it doesn't matter if someone really believes something...if it is uncivil, they shouldn't post it...] and,[...I don't think that it is supportive even to state an opinion.. ( which could IMO have the potential for you to mean that the opinion could lead a Jew to feel put down)...]and[...its OK to post what you believe as long as it does not lead another of another faith to feel put down...].
B. I also requested that as a Jewish member of this community, that I could be appoitnted a special moderator that is impartial and not a member here so that they could address posts in my behalf. Since I asked for one to be {appointed}, then I am asking you to do the appointing, if you would agree to do so. Could you make such an appointment?
C. I also requested to find out, since you write that the actions are taken by {we}, if {all} the deputies agree with the action taken or not.
D. In regards to you TOS that states:
[...it is fine to have feedback and that you want members to trust you because you want to be fair and do what in your thinking will be good for the community as a whole...], I feel that the statement in question has the potential IMO to lead Jews and others that do not accept what I think has the potential for some others to consider to be a claim made in the statement that IMO could be considered a foundation (tenet) of the Christian faith, to feel put down. I am unsure as to what you mean by that your action of allowing the statement in question to be approved by prefacing it with {I believe} when it was asked to be rephrased, which IMO could mean that it is unacceptable to post it here,because you have posted that [...it is OK to post what you believe as long as it does not have the potential to lead someone of another faith to feel put down...] because you also wrote that staments that could put down another faith are not supportive.
I am asking for you to post here your rationale for as to why it could be good for the community as a whole, taking in regards that as a Jew I feel inferior (put down) when I read the statement in question because of the grammatical structure of the statement in question that could have the potential IMO to lead a Jew to feel that his faith is being contrasted to the Christian faith in a manner that could lead a Jew to feel that that the Jewish faith is lacking in respect to what the Christian faith claims in the statement in question. If you could write your rationales here, then I could have the opportunity to respond accordingly.
Lou Pilder
poster:Lou Pilder
thread:742926
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20070304/msgs/742926.html