Posted by Lou Pilder on March 10, 2007, at 8:47:48
In reply to Lou's reminder to Dr.Hsiung-(3B), posted by Lou Pilder on March 10, 2007, at 7:30:33
> > Dr. Hsiung,
> > In response to your policy to keep reminding you, the following:
> > If you could address in any reply from you to me here the following, I would appreciate it. If you reply here, could I then have someone that is impartial, let's say a professor of history, respond to any reply thst you may post here?
> > A. What in your opinion could be the potential of the effect that the statement in question could have on the current reader toward the Jewish people, if any?
> > B. In your opinion, is there a theological aspect to the statement in question that could have the potential to arrouse antisemitic feelings?
> > C. Is there in your opinion the potential of an incitement toward the potential for the defamation of the Jewish people contained in the statement in question? If not, why not?
> > D.Could there be the potential in your opinion for the statement in question to create hostility toward the Jewish people?
> > E.Could there be in your opinion the potential for the statement in question as being written by you to be OK, that there could be two standards here because of what people of the Jewish faith believe?
> > F. other relevant issues contained in this discussion.
> > Lou Pilder
> > http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20070123/msgs/737156.html
>
> DR. Hsiung,
> In your statemet concerning the statement in question, you posted something like that you think that the statement is OK after the poster prefaced it with {I believe}.
> The statement in question could be IMO determined to be a foundation of a faith that speaks to the foundation of my faith because of the grammatical structure of the conjunction {but} and the use of {came by} in the second part of the statement. The use of {came by} could have the potential IMO for the reader to have the potential to think that {came by} could mean {after}.
> As a Jewish member of this community, I am asking that you appoint a special moderator that is impartial and not a poster, that I could email to have him/her address posts like the one in question.
> Lou PIlder
>
>Dr. Hsiung,
In response to that your policy here is that it is fine to post here about the actions (we) take and the policies here, this IMO means that the action that you have taken here in question, that you think it is OK for the statement in question to be posted if it is prefaced with {I believe}, brings up some other questions to me.
A. If it is fine to have discussion about the action that (we) take, then can one aaume that {all} the deputies agree with your action taken in question here?
B. You have posted in your TOS-FAQ something like that it is fine to have {feedback} and that you want me to trust you because you are being {fair} and doing what your thinking will be >good for the community as a whole<.
The generally accepted meaning of {to be fair} is that one is honest and that there is not favoritism and that decisions are free from self-interest or prejudice and that there is {impartiality} in moderation of the forum.
Using the grammatical structure of your statement in your TOS that we are to trust you in regards to this, the generally accepted meaning of {trust} is to have |confidence| in your actions that you take and that your actions will be {good} for the community as a whole.
I am asking you to consider your TOS for members here in regards to any reply to me that you may post here in regards to my concern about the action that you, and I guess all the deputies if you are meaning that it is an action that you write [we} take, have taken by posting something like that the statement in question is OK with the preface {I belive}.
My overiding concern here is that if I am to trust you that your action in question will be good for the community as a whole, and I feel that the statement in question has the potential to lead a Jew and myself as a Jew to feel put down even if one believes what is in the statement in question, I am unsure as to what you mean by that it will be good for the community as a whole for me to trust your action to allow the statement in question to be considered to be OK if it is prefaced with {I believe}. Could you post here why you think that your action in question will be good for the community as a whole? If you could , then I could have the opportunity to respond accordingly.
Lou Pilder
poster:Lou Pilder
thread:739745
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20070304/msgs/739756.html