Posted by Lou Pilder on April 26, 2005, at 17:12:26
In reply to Re: I don't see a difference, posted by Dr. Bob on April 26, 2005, at 0:15:36
Dr. Hsiung,
You wrote,[...tell someone that they hadn't had a problem...].
I do not see that dancinstar wrote that. What was written was:
[...Personally, I do not believe that it is a "problem" {with}...].
By leaving out the word,"with" there is, IMO, an incomplete meaning. Because with the "with" the sentence leads to that dancingstar wrote that she didn't think that there [...was a problem with {symptoms or a diagnosis}...], which I think is different. I see her statement as a point of view about the taking of psychotropic drugs ,perhaps, unnecessarrily, and that the taking of those chemicals into one's body can have an adverse effect upon one, for she wrote that [...are likely to cause ill health and lead to an earlier... death for having taken something that proves poisonous to our bodies...]. This is different, IMO, from writing that the other poster hadn't had a problem. I do not see that dancingstar wrote that the other poster hadn't had a problem. Dancingstar's post is about a problem. But it goes on to write that she personally did not believe that it is a prblem {with a diagnosis or symptoms}. Could not the problem been something different? And is that not a point of view ?
If your FAQ writes that different points of view are encouraged here, then I think that dancingstar responded to your invitation to write her point of view about ,perhaps, that there could be an alternative to taking psychotropic drugs for a problem, not that there is not a problem, because dancingstar did write that she did not believe that it was a problem with symptoms or a disagnosis and she goes on to write,[...It is...recent to treat...as if they were a problem,though I am not opposed to finding a cure for things...]. Here dancingstar writes that it is a problem. She writes that it is recent to treat as a problem, not that there is not a problem. She aknowleges that there is a problem and goes on to write,[...I'm not opposed to finding cures...]. Can there be a cure to something that is not a problem?
Lou Pilder
poster:Lou Pilder
thread:486296
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/babble/admin/20050417/msgs/489939.html