Psycho-Babble Withdrawal Thread 466069

Shown: posts 207 to 231 of 696. Go back in thread:

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP

Posted by Avalon on May 25, 2006, at 15:56:09

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by kparis on May 25, 2006, at 15:23:03

> I'm stopping my Cymbalta today. I was on 60mg for over a year, the last month on 30mg (with no side effects whatsoever) and now cold turkey. My doc said that it wouldn't be easy and if it got bad to let her know and a single dose of prozac should do the job as it has a 1/2 life of about 3 weeks. I'm a bit nervous about this, but I'm willing to do it as I want my body to be clean of all drugs. I'm feeling so great being on a lower dose. I'm also hoping that getting off of this drug will help me lose the weight I put on while on the drug. Any thoughts from anyone? Thanks!
> Kparis

Yes, please keep us posted. My withdrawal symptoms didn't start until 3 days after I stopped. (And I was only on it 3 weeks.) It will be interesting to see whether anyone is able to get off this with no withdrawal. Good luck!

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP

Posted by gapsgal on May 25, 2006, at 16:04:48

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by kparis on May 25, 2006, at 15:23:03

I actually suggested prozac to my doc and was told absolutely not because it can cause a fatal reaction.

I am so confused i dont know what to do...

> I'm stopping my Cymbalta today. I was on 60mg for over a year, the last month on 30mg (with no side effects whatsoever) and now cold turkey. My doc said that it wouldn't be easy and if it got bad to let her know and a single dose of prozac should do the job as it has a 1/2 life of about 3 weeks. I'm a bit nervous about this, but I'm willing to do it as I want my body to be clean of all drugs. I'm feeling so great being on a lower dose. I'm also hoping that getting off of this drug will help me lose the weight I put on while on the drug. Any thoughts from anyone? Thanks!
> Kparis

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP

Posted by gapsgal on May 25, 2006, at 16:09:20

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by Avalon on May 25, 2006, at 15:56:09

What mg. prozac? Yes you will need something if you plan to go cold turkey...I had gotten down to 7.5 mg before trying cold turkey and had the worst symptoms since I quit effexor...so I have no doubt you will develop them, just be prepared...I am tempted to order the prozac online and actually thought of doing just that until I asked the doctor and was told it could be potentially fatal if mixed because it could cause some type of syndrome...can you inquire with your doctor about this and see what his thoughts are?

Donna


> > I'm stopping my Cymbalta today. I was on 60mg for over a year, the last month on 30mg (with no side effects whatsoever) and now cold turkey. My doc said that it wouldn't be easy and if it got bad to let her know and a single dose of prozac should do the job as it has a 1/2 life of about 3 weeks. I'm a bit nervous about this, but I'm willing to do it as I want my body to be clean of all drugs. I'm feeling so great being on a lower dose. I'm also hoping that getting off of this drug will help me lose the weight I put on while on the drug. Any thoughts from anyone? Thanks!
> > Kparis
>
> Yes, please keep us posted. My withdrawal symptoms didn't start until 3 days after I stopped. (And I was only on it 3 weeks.) It will be interesting to see whether anyone is able to get off this with no withdrawal. Good luck!

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Jaspar

Posted by Avalon on May 25, 2006, at 16:10:28

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal, posted by Jaspar on May 15, 2006, at 12:35:18

Jaspar, first off -- how are you doing? I think you've been off C-word for 10 days or so?

Also, here's where I am in my tapering schedule: I'm on the 30 mg and have been slowly spacing them out further and further, to the point where I'm at every other day. And now I'm dumping out increasing numbers of granules each time. The doctor said they don't come any smaller than 30 mg (even though the website said they come in 20) and I don't want to contradict him since he's the one who prescribes my pain meds. I'm almost out of 30 mg pills, but I still have 60's so I think I'll just divide up the granules in each cap into lower and lower numbers. What a pain in the a**. At this rate it will be Christmas before I'm done! Does this schedule sound OK to you? Thanks.

P.S. Coincidentally, a Cymbalta commercial is on as I write this!!! Should I throw something at the TV???

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Jaspar

Posted by gapsgal on May 25, 2006, at 16:13:12

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Jaspar, posted by Avalon on May 25, 2006, at 16:10:28

Actually they do come in 20 I have them, my doctor said that are not used much though.


> Jaspar, first off -- how are you doing? I think you've been off C-word for 10 days or so?
>
> Also, here's where I am in my tapering schedule: I'm on the 30 mg and have been slowly spacing them out further and further, to the point where I'm at every other day. And now I'm dumping out increasing numbers of granules each time. The doctor said they don't come any smaller than 30 mg (even though the website said they come in 20) and I don't want to contradict him since he's the one who prescribes my pain meds. I'm almost out of 30 mg pills, but I still have 60's so I think I'll just divide up the granules in each cap into lower and lower numbers. What a pain in the a**. At this rate it will be Christmas before I'm done! Does this schedule sound OK to you? Thanks.
>
> P.S. Coincidentally, a Cymbalta commercial is on as I write this!!! Should I throw something at the TV???

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP

Posted by Doccybear on May 25, 2006, at 16:53:27

In reply to Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by Doccybear on May 25, 2006, at 12:13:05

The cymbalta has such a short half life that there shouldn't be a fatal interaction. I'm not a doctor but it's out of your blood in about 24 hours. At this time something else can replace it (I did it even sooner.)

Alot of people go from one to another like water so as long as you fully stop the other the doctors seem to do it pretty readily.

I didn't bother tapering down from Cymbalta before starting another; it would have been too hard for me.

DEFINETELY do the prozac thing. One dose, sometimes a second is necessary after a week has had really good results.

 

GapsGirl!!

Posted by Doccybear on May 25, 2006, at 16:56:40

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by gapsgal on May 25, 2006, at 16:09:20

Hi, well you can't start prozac and take ANY cymbalta at all that WOULD be potentially fatal, but you may switch immediately onto the other.

Let us know if you do Prozac; I wouldn't mind trying that one if I had to.

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Avalon

Posted by Jaspar on May 25, 2006, at 17:13:30

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Jaspar, posted by Avalon on May 25, 2006, at 16:10:28

> Jaspar, first off -- how are you doing?
> I think you've been off C-word for 10 days or so?

Instead of the weird visual thing every few minutes, I am getting it now just about a dozen or so times per day. That is immense improvement!

On the downside - my nerve pain is back full-force, and with it, muscle spasms. But it is funny - after going through the depression and torture of withdrawal, I view the nerve & muscle pain as relative... I am going to learn to live with it a different way.

>
> I'm at every other day.

I chose to take it EVERY day, but just in decreasing amounts. I could not go a day without the C-word without severe symptoms.

>The doctor said they don't come any smaller than 30 mg

I had 20mg pills. It May be more difficult with 30mg but the process is the same.

You can ask the doctor to just write out the prescription for the 20mg and you'll worry about getting it (since you know it exists).

> At this rate it will be Christmas before I'm done!
> Does this schedule sound OK to you? Thanks.

What can I say... it took me 6 months to come off the 60mg. The slowest part was the last 10-15mg or so.


> P.S. Coincidentally, a Cymbalta commercial is on as I write this!!! Should I throw something at the TV???

Only if it is soft. My family might be tired of hearing me rant everytime the commercial comes on, but I guess they are polite and don't say anything.

-Jaspar

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP

Posted by Jaspar on May 25, 2006, at 17:17:23

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by gapsgal on May 25, 2006, at 15:01:24

> My doctor told me it could cause some syndrome
> that is potentially fatal to switch before I
> am completely off of the Cymbalta.

Serotonin Syndrome.


> The doctors are oh so amazed that I am having
> withdrawals at all.

Mine also. I guess the pharamceutical reps negelected to tell him that part.

-Jaspar

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP

Posted by gapsgal on May 25, 2006, at 17:24:43

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by Doccybear on May 25, 2006, at 16:53:27

What strenght prozac? Just get up and instead of taking Cymbalta take prozac? and then dont worry about it after that one dose?

> The cymbalta has such a short half life that there shouldn't be a fatal interaction. I'm not a doctor but it's out of your blood in about 24 hours. At this time something else can replace it (I did it even sooner.)
>
> Alot of people go from one to another like water so as long as you fully stop the other the doctors seem to do it pretty readily.
>
> I didn't bother tapering down from Cymbalta before starting another; it would have been too hard for me.
>
> DEFINETELY do the prozac thing. One dose, sometimes a second is necessary after a week has had really good results.

 

Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity

Posted by Avalon on May 25, 2006, at 18:58:08

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by gapsgal on May 25, 2006, at 17:24:43

Since none of us know much about how to get a class-action suit started, at least we can try to make the public aware of this problem. I just sent an e-mail to the health reporter at our local news station (in a major city). I've heard them do stories like this before, so I suggested publicizing this as a warning to anyone considering Cymbalta, especially since the commercials are so visible these days. We'll see how it goes. They may not want to do a negative story about a sponsor, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't try. I think if we all start to spread the word on this, it could really make a difference! What do you think, folks?

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP

Posted by kparis on May 26, 2006, at 7:11:19

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by gapsgal on May 25, 2006, at 17:24:43

> What strenght prozac? Just get up and instead of taking Cymbalta take prozac? and then dont worry about it after that one dose?

I'm not sure. I didn't ask. But I'll let you all know when I find out.

I'm off completely for 36 hours now with no withdrawal symtoms yet. Maybe it is too early to tell.

KParis
>
>
>
>
>
> > The cymbalta has such a short half life that there shouldn't be a fatal interaction. I'm not a doctor but it's out of your blood in about 24 hours. At this time something else can replace it (I did it even sooner.)
> >
> > Alot of people go from one to another like water so as long as you fully stop the other the doctors seem to do it pretty readily.
> >
> > I didn't bother tapering down from Cymbalta before starting another; it would have been too hard for me.
> >
> > DEFINETELY do the prozac thing. One dose, sometimes a second is necessary after a week has had really good results.
>
>

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » Avalon

Posted by secretme on May 26, 2006, at 9:27:08

In reply to Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity, posted by Avalon on May 25, 2006, at 18:58:08

Unfortunately, I don't live in New York City, but the New York Times has a day on which there is a section devoted to Science (Science Times?). They might consider doing a story on this. Also, The Wall Street Journal has a science writer/reporter who might be willing to listen. The edit page is conservative, but the rest of the paper usually is not. And these newspapers have all the advertising they need, so telling the truth about Cymbalta shouldn't hurt their revenue.

In reading the flurry of postings lately, I worry about some of the advice on mixing medications. What is good for one person may not be good for another, and something significant could happen to permanently injure someone. My family wanted to admit me to the hospital because my withdrawal symptoms were so serious. Using the Benadryl seemed to be the most benign antidote, and it did help. At the same time, I HAD to take my cancer medication, BP medication, a statin, and withstand all the side effects in combination with Cymbalta withdrawal. My oncologist told me that while getting rid of this medication to drink lots of water. It helps get this crap out of your system.

secretme

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP

Posted by secretme on May 26, 2006, at 9:43:28

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal GOOD NEWS / Trying to HELP, posted by kparis on May 26, 2006, at 7:11:19

By the way, there is a Dr. Bob, right? Can't he weigh in on some of these postings, or is there some kind of legal/ethical issue preventing him from responding? Do you think he still reads all this? Personally, I'd like to know HE is there and listening. How about it, Dr. Bob? Do our exchanges help you in treatment, education, etc.?

secretme

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity

Posted by SLS on May 26, 2006, at 10:24:09

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » Avalon, posted by secretme on May 26, 2006, at 9:27:08

Hi.

Do you think that publicity and more visible caution statements are enough, or would you like to see Cymbalta removed from the market?


- Scott

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity

Posted by gapsgal on May 26, 2006, at 10:36:12

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity, posted by SLS on May 26, 2006, at 10:24:09

I just fired this letter off to my local paper...

The anti-depressant age...

It seems that we now live in an anti-depressant world, me included. The problem is that not enough people including health-care providers are up-to-snuff on these various drugs. Two in particular (that seem to be given like candy around here) are Effexor and Cymbalta. The benefits of taking these drugs seems wonderful...that is until you have to quit taking them. Then your nightmare will begin or at least millions which can be heard on many online forums, articles and books. In fact I purchased a book written by a medical doctor telling about anti-depressants and withdrawal syndromes.

I have taken both of the above named drugs and in fact I am still taking Cymbalta, not because I want to mind you, but because the withdrawal is so devastating that I could not possibly function in daily life while enduring it. Even the smallest of tapers produces withdrawals and it could take months to withdraw without incident. For some reason unknown to me and so many others is that our physicians have no idea of this or why we are experiencing this, hello short half-life. Perhaps they believe the drug reps, after all would they lie just to sell their product and protect their company...never...yeah right. But they seem to take their word for this and dispense it like sweet-tarts.

In fact I have been to more than one doctor to inquire about this withdrawal night mare and they had no idea that this produced such bad withdrawals. I fully understand why drug addicts do the things that they do to get “their fix” now. The sad thing is that we are given no warning about how it may be when we can finally be rid of the poison (yes I consider it poison).

The drug companies should offer a taper program and the doctors should be more informed on this issue. This is just a partial list of complaints with these drugs, not to mention the damage that can be caused by them to for instance your liver and no one knows the long-term effects this could have.

The fact is no one could possibly know how this effects a person or their lives unless they themselves have been in the load baring shoes. I am sure there a few people who do not experience such harsh withdrawals, and who knows why and who cares...least of all those of us that do. The fact is that millions are experiencing this and it is going on and no one cares and doctors look at you as if you are over-reacting...listen doctors take this for about a year or two yourselves and then try discontinuing.

The point is it is not worth it, and doctors should strongly caution and warn patients of the possibility of these happenings. They should not dispense it so readily and should always monitor their patients withdrawal period more closely. The withdrawal schedules I was given by one of my doctors was laughable.

If this keeps just one person from going through the atrocity of withdrawal from these drugs then it has been worth it to put my name out there for scrutiny.

Donna


> Hi.
>
> Do you think that publicity and more visible caution statements are enough, or would you like to see Cymbalta removed from the market?
>
>
> - Scott

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity

Posted by Jaspar on May 26, 2006, at 10:58:25

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity, posted by SLS on May 26, 2006, at 10:24:09

> Do you think that publicity and more visible caution statements are enough,
> or would you like to see Cymbalta removed from the market?
> - Scott

I would NOT like to see Cymbalta removed from the market. I LIKE there being various meds to choose from because for SOME people, THIS IS the "RIGHT" med for THEM. There are some people who are desperate and have tried everything else. In fact, I know somebody with a heart condition about to go on it, and she understands the risks. But if it works for her she might NEVER go off it during the remainder of her life, and I am praying that THIS drug will be what she needs. She has suffered a lot.

No - don't throw the baby out with the bath water.

What is needed is TESTING to give KNOWLEDGE - BEFORE starting the med. We need to know who should NOT take this drug.

-Jaspar

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » SLS

Posted by secretme on May 26, 2006, at 12:41:10

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity, posted by SLS on May 26, 2006, at 10:24:09

Cymbalta needs to be taken off the market. The FDA waited to take Vioxx off the market until patients were being hit with heart conditions. There may even have been some deaths. For some reason, people do not consider anti-depressants as "dangerous" because science knows so much less about how the brain works than the heart or kidneys or lungs. So really, they have no firm data as to why they work or what the long-term effects will be. (Said to my son by the psychiatrist: "we don't know why Cymbalta helps people with OCD, but it does." -- over my dead body!)

I worked for the WSJ for 15 years. Before sending any letters or persuasive information for printing, it's a good idea to make lists of side effects and withdrawal symptoms and why we believe this medication should be taken off the market. The information has to be sucsinct and addressed to a reporter who will follow it through. This will take a few telephone calls to The Times or any local newspaper. Once you have a name, call the reporter to find out if he/she is interested in the information. Then don't let up on them. There are a bunch of us here who will be good sources of information and corroboration for the demonic Cymbalta problems. When I took this medication, I was sick while on it. My psychiatrist did everything to convince me I needed a gastroenterologist or cardiologist or endocrinologist, etc., to help me with my complaints; they were not, he said, related to Cymbalta. He never even took my blood pressure during those 15 minute office visits, and my BP continued to go up despite taking three BP medications. Cymbalta did nothing for me but make me sick while I was on it and worse when I tried to get off it. My psychiatrist's explanation just encouraged me to allow him to INCREASE the dose of this terrible stuff. Was I less depressed while taking Cymbalta? I had too many other physical problems to even think about depression. It reminds me of the old gag line, "other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?" Time to get rid of this drug and hold the pharmaceutical company AND THE FDA accountable for their actions. Anyone read Mother Jones or even Newsweek? Find out how the pharmaceutical companies only show the positive clinical trials to the FDA -- believe it or not, there is legislation that recently passed FORCING these bums to show the results of ALL CLINICAL TRIALS, not just the ones that make their medication look good for marketing.

secretme

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity

Posted by gapsgal on May 26, 2006, at 13:32:30

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » SLS, posted by secretme on May 26, 2006, at 12:41:10

I am with you all the way! I have sent in to several different papers in my state and plan to go further...I have also reported this to the FDA. They should not be allowed to do this to people and then pretend they didnt.

> Cymbalta needs to be taken off the market. The FDA waited to take Vioxx off the market until patients were being hit with heart conditions. There may even have been some deaths. For some reason, people do not consider anti-depressants as "dangerous" because science knows so much less about how the brain works than the heart or kidneys or lungs. So really, they have no firm data as to why they work or what the long-term effects will be. (Said to my son by the psychiatrist: "we don't know why Cymbalta helps people with OCD, but it does." -- over my dead body!)
>
> I worked for the WSJ for 15 years. Before sending any letters or persuasive information for printing, it's a good idea to make lists of side effects and withdrawal symptoms and why we believe this medication should be taken off the market. The information has to be sucsinct and addressed to a reporter who will follow it through. This will take a few telephone calls to The Times or any local newspaper. Once you have a name, call the reporter to find out if he/she is interested in the information. Then don't let up on them. There are a bunch of us here who will be good sources of information and corroboration for the demonic Cymbalta problems. When I took this medication, I was sick while on it. My psychiatrist did everything to convince me I needed a gastroenterologist or cardiologist or endocrinologist, etc., to help me with my complaints; they were not, he said, related to Cymbalta. He never even took my blood pressure during those 15 minute office visits, and my BP continued to go up despite taking three BP medications. Cymbalta did nothing for me but make me sick while I was on it and worse when I tried to get off it. My psychiatrist's explanation just encouraged me to allow him to INCREASE the dose of this terrible stuff. Was I less depressed while taking Cymbalta? I had too many other physical problems to even think about depression. It reminds me of the old gag line, "other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?" Time to get rid of this drug and hold the pharmaceutical company AND THE FDA accountable for their actions. Anyone read Mother Jones or even Newsweek? Find out how the pharmaceutical companies only show the positive clinical trials to the FDA -- believe it or not, there is legislation that recently passed FORCING these bums to show the results of ALL CLINICAL TRIALS, not just the ones that make their medication look good for marketing.
>
> secretme

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity some phone #'s

Posted by gapsgal on May 26, 2006, at 14:40:14

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » SLS, posted by secretme on May 26, 2006, at 12:41:10

FDA's Consumer Complaint Coordinators

To report adverse reactions or other problems with FDA-regulated products, contact the FDA district office consumer complaint coordinator for your geographic area. If you require the use of a Relay Service, please call the Federal Relay Services (1-800-877-8339). This is a toll free relay service to call Federal agencies from TTY devices.
Alabama--(615) 781-5385, ext. 123
Alaska--(425) 483-4949
Arizona--(949) 608-3530
Arkansas--(214) 253-5200, ext. 5233
California (Northern)--(510) 337-6741
California (Southern)--(949) 608-3530
Colorado--(303) 236-3044
Connecticut--(781) 596-7700
Delaware--(215) 597-9064
District of Columbia--(410) 779-5713
Florida -- (866) 337-6272
Georgia--(404) 253-1169
Hawaii--(510) 337-6741
Idaho--(425) 483-4949
Illinois--(312) 353-7840
Indiana--(313) 393-8100
Iowa--(913) 752-2440
Kansas--(913) 752-2440
Kentucky--(513) 679-2700, ext. 124
Louisiana--504-253-4511
Maine--(781) 596-7700
Maryland--(410) 779-5713
Massachusetts--(781) 596-7700
Michigan--(313) 393-8100
Minnesota--(612) 758-7221
Mississippi--504-253-4511
Missouri--(913) 752-2440
Montana--(425) 483-4949
Nebraska--(913) 752-2440
Nevada--(510) 337-6741
New Hampshire--(781) 596-7700
New Jersey--(973) 526-6017
New Mexico--(303) 236-3044
New York (Northern)--(716) 551-4461, ext. 3171
New York (Southern)--(718) 340-7000, ext. 5588
North Carolina--(404) 253-1169
North Dakota--(612) 758-7221
Ohio--(513) 679-2700, ext. 124
Oklahoma--(214) 253-5200, ext. 5233
Oregon--(425) 483-4949
Pennsylvania--(215) 597-9064
Rhode Island--(781) 596-7700
South Carolina--(404) 253-1169
South Dakota--(612) 758-7221
Tennessee--(615) 781-5380, ext. 123
Texas--(214) 253-5200 ext. 5233
Utah--(303) 236-3044
Vermont--(781) 596-7700
Virginia--(410) 779-5713
Washington--(425) 483-4949
West Virginia--(410) 779-5713
Wisconsin--(612) 758-7221
Wyoming--(303) 236-3044
Puerto Rico, U.S. Virgin Islands--(787) 474-9502

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity some phone #'s

Posted by Nick K. on May 26, 2006, at 17:43:02

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity some phone #'s, posted by gapsgal on May 26, 2006, at 14:40:14

This is great. I'm glad people are motivated to take action to make their experience and opinion known regarding this issue. I am one of these people and I am working on my own contribution to this effort as well. Thanks to gapsgal and secretme especially, for standing out.

I'd like to deliver my 2 cents:
I have been relatively naive/ignorant in terms of business and marketing, until recently. I am in the process of forming an e-commerce supplement/herbal retail endeavor, and consequently, I have been learning about pharmaceutical marketing and, unfortunately, about the desperate greed, dishonesty, and deception involved in most of these companies trying to push their products for sale to the public as quickly as possible. Practices involving manipulated test results and "financially influenced" research scientists are all too common.
To my dismay, and from a profit perspective, it has become painfully obvious that the anti-depressant industry, especially as of recently (effexor/cymbalta), is essentially an extremely advanced and intelligent scheme designed to "hook" as many people as possible into paying (or having insurance companies pay) in many cases $200 or more per month for medication that costs, at the most, a dollar or two to manufacture. The difficulties of withdrawal are of benefit to these companies (and perhaps an intentional side-effect), because it means the customer cannot comfortably abstain from intake, therefore they continue to pay (directly or indirectly) for the product and billion dollar profits continue to rise. In theory, the invariable side-effect of significantly decreased libido and sex drive could also be an intentional side-effect, with the hopes that those suffering from depression won't be compelled to reproduce, thus promoting "natural selection".

Many of us are being taken advantage of in horrible ways, and what's more is that we don't even realize it.

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity

Posted by SLS on May 26, 2006, at 18:38:40

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity, posted by Jaspar on May 26, 2006, at 10:58:25

> > Do you think that publicity and more visible caution statements are enough,
> > or would you like to see Cymbalta removed from the market?

> I would NOT like to see Cymbalta removed from the market. I LIKE there being various meds to choose from because for SOME people, THIS IS the "RIGHT" med for THEM.

I agree with you.

It is unfortunate that we don't yet have drugs that will successfully treat everyone. Until there are better drugs, we need all the help we can get.

The problem here seems to be one of informed consent. People are very angry that they were not told there were withdrawal effects from discontinuing antidepressant medication. People want someone to blame. Blame the drug? The drug is what it is.

We accept that drugs for other illnesses have significant health risks involved with their administration. Why should depression be treated differently?


- Scott

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » SLS

Posted by secretme on May 26, 2006, at 19:08:24

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity, posted by SLS on May 26, 2006, at 18:38:40

I don't get it: how many SSRIs are necessary in the marketplace? From what I have learned about the medications I have taken in the past 12 years, most of them do the same thing (whatever that is). None of them worked for me, so basically, they were all the same: ineffective. Cymbalta is a different story. IT IS EXTREMELY DANGEROUS!

If you had any idea of what the pharmaceutical lobby in this country does to legislation, our healthcare system, Medicare benefits and the ability to put medications on the market that are not safe, you would not agree that all these formulations are necessary. After all, who is paying for this stuff? We (and our loathesome insurance companies) are forking over billions for these medications which, in many cases, did not do anything more than a placebo. These stastics are available in the Journal of American Medicine and other scholarly publications. My psychiatrist did not deny this statistic, but he also did not say why, then, depression alone required a medication that was only 10% more effective than a water pill.

As I take medicine for cancer, high BP and cholesterol, I am grateful for those that have helped me. That doesn't mean we should give the industry a blank check to kill us!

secretme

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » secretme

Posted by SLS on May 26, 2006, at 20:21:02

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » SLS, posted by secretme on May 26, 2006, at 19:08:24

> I don't get it: how many SSRIs are necessary in the marketplace?

As many as it takes, I guess.

> From what I have learned about the medications I have taken in the past 12 years, most of them do the same thing (whatever that is).

What I have learned is that two people can respond quite disparately to the same drug.

> None of them worked for me, so basically, they were all the same: ineffective.

This might be true for you, but I don't think you can generalize your personal experiences to the rest of the population. These drugs are not all the same. I respond differently to different SRIs. I have different side effects from different SRIs. I have seen that my reactions to these drugs can be different from those of others. These are common scenarios. I believe these drugs are different enough to justify their continued availability.

What makes Cymbalta extremely dangerous?


- Scott

 

Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » SLS

Posted by secretme on May 26, 2006, at 20:54:06

In reply to Re: Cymbalta withdrawal - Publicity » secretme, posted by SLS on May 26, 2006, at 20:21:02

I don't think I'm the only one who believes Cymbalta is extremely dangerous. When my own family thought I was close to a serious medical emergency due to the withdrawal from this medication, then it is extremely dangerous. When my oncologist said to stop taking Cymbalta as soon as possible, she believed it was dangerous. There are also a host of people who have shared their stories on this website, and if you don't see any danger in what they have said about their illnesses, then there is no reason for you to stop taking Cymbalta. There are plenty of people who thought they could not live without Vioxx; they would still take it if it were available. Then why shouldn't the FDA allow them to take it? Sorry to disagree with you, but we have all been privvy to many horrific accounts from people who are desperate for help to get off Cymbalta without losing their jobs or harming themselves. If this doesn't signal danger, then this website doesn't need to exist. SSRIs serve a purpose; my son takes one for OCD. If Cymbalta were never developed, I doubt there would be a panic among people who need SSRIs for depression and other biochemical disorders.

secretme


Go forward in thread:


Show another thread

URL of post in thread:


Psycho-Babble Withdrawal | Extras | FAQ


[dr. bob] Dr. Bob is Robert Hsiung, MD, bob@dr-bob.org

Script revised: February 4, 2008
URL: http://www.dr-bob.org/cgi-bin/pb/mget.pl
Copyright 2006-17 Robert Hsiung.
Owned and operated by Dr. Bob LLC and not the University of Chicago.